Показать сообщение отдельно
Старый 19-02-2010, 21:22   #484
goldorak
Sergeant
 
Регистрация: Dec 2008
Сообщений: 250
Цитата:
Сообщение от Гена Посмотреть сообщение
It is not good idea about "TIW". Acoustic makes such a report immediately after torpedo is detected. This is not duty of commanding officer to search for torps. Moreover this is a highest degree of danger for sub. It must be primary, urgent report.
And it is a stupid situation, fatally stupid: acoustic is hearing torpedo noise but isn't making report. He's is just waiting until torpedo will be at 3 mile distance while commanding officer may know nothing about this mortally dangerous situation.
I don't agree. Monitoring the sonar station is the primary duty of a DW player, its the most important station and the only one (together with tma but this is most alwatys left on auto) that gives you a complete tactical picture.
If you're not a good enough player to descriminate civilian tracks, from possibile sub tracks, from possibile torpedo tracks well its your problem.
Does it mean playing now becomes harder ? Yes it does, but don't you like a challege when you see one ?

In any case you're still getting the TIW for subrocs launches even at great distances. But torpedo lauches are much quieter even in real life. So it makes sense to get the warning (when the weapon is near you) although you can still see the track on the sonar from far away.
Some subs such as the Type 212 don't even launch torpedoes from the inner tubes. They slide them out of the submarine on a tray and then launch them.
No compressed air is used, so its a much quieter mode of operation.
goldorak вне форума   Ответить с цитированием